Skip to content
Whitefish Bay
←  All guides

Milwaukee County

Whitefish Bay

Lake bluff streets, a walkable village, and the school district that drives most of the demand.

Median sale price
$712,000
Typical days on market
11
Housing stock
Mostly 1915–1955
The honest version

Whitefish Bay is the North Shore suburb people picture when they picture the North Shore: 1920s revival architecture on tight, tree-canopied lots, a genuine downtown along Silver Spring Drive, and Lake Michigan a short walk east down almost any street.

Inventory turns over quickly and rarely quietly. Buyers should expect to compete on the well-prepared houses between $600K and $1.1M, and should be pre-underwritten rather than merely pre-approved before touring. Sellers should expect that the difference between a good week and a great one is almost entirely preparation.

Worth knowing

  • Klode Park
  • Silver Spring Drive
  • Big Bay Park bluff stairs
  • Cahill Square
In Whitefish Bay

Our listings here

4712 N. Lake Forest Avenue, Whitefish BayActive

Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

$1,295,000

4712 N. Lake Forest Avenue

A Mediterranean revival two blocks off the lake bluff, with the original leaded glass intact and a kitchen rebuilt in 2021.

Bedrooms
4 Bed
Bathrooms
3.5 Bath
Square feet
3,840 Sq Ft
Year built
Built 1927
Listed byChevonna DavisCHE Realty & Design LLC · Realtor.com
Also worth reading
Next step

Start with a conversation, not a contract.

A consultation is thirty minutes at your kitchen table or over the phone. You leave with a number, a timeline, and a plan — whether or not you ever list with us.